Am I Nonbinary or Faking It? 19 Signs You Might Be on the Gender Spectrum

Reading time: 8 minutes

Table of Contents

• Understanding Nonbinary Identity
• 19 Signs You Might Be Nonbinary
• The Questioning Journey
• Gender Imposter Syndrome
• Finding Your Community
• Embracing Your Authentic Self: Moving Forward
• Frequently Asked Questions

Understanding Nonbinary Identity

Gender identity exists on a spectrum rather than in rigid binary categories. Nonbinary individuals experience their gender outside the traditional male/female binary, encompassing a wide range of identities and expressions that might feel more fluid, neutral, or entirely different from conventional gender categories.

According to the Trevor Project’s 2022 National Survey on LGBTQ Youth Mental Health, approximately 26% of LGBTQ+ youth identify as nonbinary, with another 20% questioning or exploring their gender identity. These numbers highlight how common it is to explore gender beyond traditional boundaries.

The journey of questioning your gender identity is deeply personal and often complex. Many nonbinary individuals describe experiencing a persistent sense of disconnect with their assigned gender at birth—a feeling that something about societal gender expectations simply doesn’t fit.

The Difference Between Gender Identity, Expression, and Biological Sex

Understanding these distinct concepts can help clarify your own experience:

• Biological Sex: Physical characteristics like chromosomes, hormones, and anatomy present at birth
• Gender Identity: Your internal, deeply-held sense of your gender
• Gender Expression: How you present your gender externally through clothing, behavior, and appearance

For nonbinary folks, these elements might not align in conventional ways. You might have a female body (sex), feel neither fully female nor male (identity), and express yourself in ways that blend or transcend traditional gender presentations.

Common Nonbinary Identities

Nonbinary is an umbrella term encompassing numerous gender identities, including:

• Genderfluid: Identity shifts between different genders over time
• Agender: Absence of gender or gender neutrality
• Bigender: Experiencing two distinct gender identities
• Demigender: Partial connection to a particular gender
• Genderqueer: Identity outside conventional gender categories

Dr. Alex Iantaffi, gender therapist and author of “How to Understand Your Gender,” explains: “Many people experience gender as more complex than simply ‘man’ or ‘woman.’ These experiences are valid and have existed across cultures and throughout history. Questioning and exploring your gender identity is a healthy part of understanding yourself more deeply.”

19 Signs You Might Be Nonbinary

If you’re wondering whether you might be nonbinary, consider the following signs. Remember, you don’t need to experience all of these to identify as nonbinary—these are simply common experiences that might resonate with you.

Internal Feelings and Thoughts

1. Persistent Discomfort: You’ve long felt uncomfortable being categorized strictly as male or female.
2. Relief in Neutral Terms: You feel a sense of comfort or relief when using gender-neutral terms for yourself.
3. Binary Limitation: The concept of being either “man” or “woman” feels restrictive or incomplete for describing who you are.
4. Inner Identity Fluctuation: Your sense of gender shifts over time or in different contexts.
5. Mixed Internal Experience: You feel like a mix of genders or like you have aspects of multiple genders simultaneously.
6. Gender Neutrality: You feel most authentic when thinking of yourself in gender-neutral terms.
7. Detachment: You feel detached from or indifferent toward your assigned gender at birth.

External Expression and Social Interactions

8. Pronoun Comfort: You feel more comfortable with they/them pronouns or multiple sets of pronouns.
9. Expression Freedom: You enjoy expressing yourself in ways that blend or transcend traditional gender norms.
10. Gendered Compliments: Being described as a “handsome man” or “beautiful woman” feels off or uncomfortable, even when intended positively.
11. Gender Envy: You feel drawn to or envious of androgynous or nonbinary presentations.
12. Mixed Clothing Preferences: You prefer mixing clothing styles traditionally associated with different genders or gravitate toward androgynous fashion.

Reflections and Realizations

13. Nonbinary Resonance: Learning about nonbinary identities creates an “aha” moment or sense of recognition.
14. Community Connection: You feel a strong connection to nonbinary communities and experiences.
15. Dysphoria Experience: You experience gender dysphoria (discomfort with gendered aspects of your body or how others perceive your gender) that doesn’t fit the typical binary transgender narrative.
16. Past Indicators: Looking back, you recognize childhood or adolescent signs of gender nonconformity.
17. Binary Resistance: You’ve always felt resistant to being categorized by gender in forms, surveys, or social situations.
18. Identity Exploration: You find yourself consistently questioning your gender identity over time.
19. Authentic Recognition: Being recognized as nonbinary feels right and authentic.

The Questioning Journey

Questioning your gender identity is a deeply personal process that looks different for everyone. For many nonbinary individuals, this journey isn’t linear and may involve periods of uncertainty, experimentation, and self-discovery.

Common Questioning Experiences

The path to understanding your gender identity often includes:

• Experimentation: Trying different pronouns, names, or expressions to see what feels right
• Research: Learning about various gender identities and experiences
• Community: Connecting with others who share similar experiences
• Reflection: Examining past experiences through a new lens
• Professional Support: Working with affirming therapists or counselors

According to a 2021 study published in the International Journal of Transgender Health, individuals who question their gender identity often report that exploration and experimentation with gender expression are crucial steps in their self-discovery process. Over 78% of participants indicated that having a supportive environment during questioning significantly improved their mental health outcomes.

Exploration Tools and Exercises

Consider these practical approaches to explore your gender identity:

1. Journaling: Write about how you feel about your gender in different contexts or situations
2. Pronoun Testing: Ask trusted friends to use different pronouns and notice how each makes you feel
3. Clothing Exploration: Experiment with clothing that feels authentic, regardless of which gender section it comes from
4. Name Exploration: Try different names in safe environments or online spaces
5. Visualization: Imagine yourself in different scenarios with different gender presentations

Remember that questioning doesn’t necessarily mean you’ll arrive at a nonbinary identity. The goal is authentic self-understanding, whatever that looks like for you.

Gender Imposter Syndrome

Many people questioning their gender identity experience what’s often called “gender imposter syndrome”—doubting the authenticity of their identity or feeling like they’re “not nonbinary enough.” This is incredibly common and doesn’t invalidate your experience.

Comparing Genuine Exploration vs. “Faking It”

Here’s the reality: people who are “faking” their gender identity know they’re doing so. The very fact that you’re concerned about authenticity suggests your questioning is genuine. As nonbinary author and activist Alok Vaid-Menon puts it: “The very fear of ‘faking it’ is evidence that you’re not.”

Common Doubts and Internalized Messages

Many nonbinary individuals encounter these doubts during their journey:

• “I’m not androgynous enough”: Nonbinary people don’t need to look androgynous
• “I sometimes feel OK with my assigned gender”: Gender feelings can fluctuate
• “I didn’t show signs as a child”: Many discover their identity later in life
• “I’m comfortable with some aspects of my body”: Not all nonbinary people experience physical dysphoria
• “Maybe it’s just a phase”: Identity exploration is valid regardless of outcome

Gender therapist Dr. Laura Erickson-Schroth notes: “Many of my nonbinary clients experience significant doubt about their identity’s validity. This doubt often stems from internalized cultural messages about what ‘real’ gender identities look like. Working through these messages is an important part of the gender journey.”

Finding Your Community

Connection with others who share similar experiences can be invaluable during your gender exploration journey. Community support provides validation, resources, and the comfort of knowing you’re not alone.

Representation and Visibility

Seeing yourself reflected in others’ experiences can be profoundly affirming. Nonbinary representation has grown significantly in recent years, with public figures like Demi Lovato, Sam Smith, Jonathan Van Ness, and Janelle Monáe sharing their nonbinary identities.

According to a 2022 GLAAD Media Institute report, 76% of nonbinary youth reported that seeing nonbinary representation in media positively impacted their self-acceptance journey.

Resources and Support

Consider exploring these resources as you navigate your gender journey:

• Online Communities: Platforms like Reddit (r/nonbinary), Discord servers, and social media groups
• LGBTQ+ Centers: Local organizations often host nonbinary and gender-expansive support groups
• Mental Health Support: Therapists specializing in gender identity (resources available through the World Professional Association for Transgender Health)
• Educational Resources: Books like “Gender Queer” by Maia Kobabe or “Beyond the Gender Binary” by Alok Vaid-Menon
• Helplines: The Trevor Project and Trans Lifeline offer support services

Finding community doesn’t mean you need to immediately label yourself or make any permanent decisions. Many spaces welcome those who are questioning and exploring.

Embracing Your Authentic Self: Moving Forward

Wherever you are in your gender journey—just beginning to question, confidently identifying as nonbinary, or somewhere in between—here are practical steps to support your path forward:

Your Personal Gender Exploration Roadmap

1. Create safe exploration spaces: Identify environments where you can express your gender authentically without judgment. This might be with specific friends, online communities, or LGBTQ+ spaces.
2. Experiment with expression: Try different clothing, hairstyles, pronouns, or names that feel affirming. Notice what brings you comfort and joy.
3. Develop supportive connections: Cultivate relationships with people who affirm your identity journey, whether friends, family, or community members.
4. Set boundaries: You don’t owe anyone definitions or explanations. Practice responses for uncomfortable questions and learn when to engage or disengage.
5. Prioritize self-compassion: Recognize that doubt, confusion, and changing feelings are normal parts of the journey. Be as kind to yourself as you would be to a friend.

Remember that your timeline is your own. There’s no rush to figure everything out immediately, and it’s okay for your understanding of your gender to evolve over time.

As nonbinary activist Jeffrey Marsh writes: “You don’t discover your authentic self like finding buried treasure—you create it through exploration, contemplation, and courageous self-honesty.”

The most important question isn’t whether you’re “really” nonbinary—it’s whether exploring gender beyond binary conventions helps you feel more authentic, comfortable, and aligned with yourself. Trust your internal compass more than external validation or arbitrary “qualifications.”

How might your life feel different if you gave yourself complete permission to explore your gender without judgment or pressure? What small step could you take today toward better understanding yourself?

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I be nonbinary if I don’t experience dysphoria?

Absolutely. While some nonbinary individuals experience gender dysphoria (discomfort with gendered aspects of their body or how they’re perceived), many don’t. Gender euphoria—positive feelings when your gender is affirmed—can be equally important. Dr. Jamison Green, transgender health advocate, emphasizes: “The absence of dysphoria doesn’t invalidate someone’s gender identity. Many nonbinary people experience their gender primarily through comfort, connection, and rightness rather than through distress.”

If I’m questioning my gender, does that automatically mean I’m nonbinary?

No, questioning your gender doesn’t automatically mean you’re nonbinary or transgender. Many cisgender people (those whose gender identity matches their assigned sex at birth) may explore their relationship with gender roles and expression without their core identity being nonbinary. Exploration is valuable regardless of where you land. Some people question and confirm they’re cisgender, others discover they’re nonbinary or transgender, and some find that different language better captures their experience. All paths are valid.

Can my nonbinary identity change over time?

Yes. Gender is complex and can be fluid for many people. Some nonbinary individuals experience their gender consistently over time, while others find their gender identity evolves or fluctuates. Some people initially identify as nonbinary and later identify differently, while others move from binary identities to nonbinary ones. According to research published in the Journal of Adolescent Health, approximately 58% of nonbinary youth report experiencing some degree of gender fluidity. These evolutions don’t invalidate any part of your journey—they simply reflect your growing self-understanding.